Life or Death Decisions
Monday, March 31st, 2008Winning the War on Drugs in Columbia, South Carolina.
A Richland County woman is being charged with dealing drugs after her husband was killed by a sheriff’s deputy in a drug raid Wednesday.
Richland County Sheriff Leon Lott says April Bosket was fully aware of her husband’s actions, and is therefore responsible. “There’s no doubt she knew those drugs were in her bedroom. There’s no doubt she knew what he was doing.”
A deputy was wounded and the suspect killed in a shooting off Laredo Drive near Broad River Road and I-20 on Wednesday morning.
Richland County Coroner Gary Watts identified the shooting victim as 34-year-old Larry Darnell Bosket.
Investigators say a photo taken March third shows Bosket caught in the act of selling pot to a couple of teenagers near Broad River Road. Richland County Sheriff Leon Lott says deputies seized a bag of marijuana from that sale….
That same uncertainty is why April Bosket says her husband fired first. “We have had our home broken into before. That’s the purpose of being that ready when someone intrudes.”
“If you hear that noise and it wakes you up out of your sleep, what’s your first natural instinct is to protect your family and your home. He reached for his gun and he shot.”
Each time I post one of these Winning the War on Drugs pieces over on Slog, there’s a mixed reaction in comments of rage at the officers, rage at the drug dealers, and rage at me. The theme in most of the posts – that someone is shot and killed in a drug raid – is enraging. No doubt. But there’s a reason I keep posting them, even if, although they are verbatim news clips, they seem a little sensationalistic. It’s to pose a question.
But the question, as per this story, isn’t whether selling drugs to kids should be a punishable offense. Of course it should be. The question isn’t whether cops should return fire at people who are shooting at them. They must. The question also isn’t whether armed raids are among the tactics cops should use. Sometimes they are. And it’s not whether drugs should be outlawed. That’s a bigger ball of wax. This is it: Is raiding a private residence in the middle of the night with guns drawn the right way to enforce suspected nonviolent drug-law violations?
Now, I imagine some people would say that this guy shot a cop and so obviously he’s violent. Thus, a violent raid is justified. But the house wasn’t being raided to enforce a suspected violent crime, according to this news report, and Bosket became violent only when woken up in the middle of the night by an armed stranger charging down his hallway. In this country, it’s legal for most folks to have a gun in their house, and a lot of completely law-abiding citizens will fire their gun at anyone who trespasses in the middle of the night—cop or not.
Some would also say an armed raid is necessary to avoid a violent confrontation on the street. And that is always a possibility. But that doesn’t seem likely here, Bosket was suspected of selling marijuana. Besides, hundreds of thousands of arrests are made each year, of nonviolent and violent offenders, without resorting to armed raids. Normal enforcement practices seem to work fine. Suspected drug offenses are often singled out for armed drug raids.
There’s just too much collateral damage to cops, bystanders, and suspected nonviolent offenders to justify armed raids unless it’s necessary. Innocent people are shot and/or killed—like this one-year-old baby and his mom. Officers are killed, like this officer, who was raiding a house that turned out to have a maple tree that looked like pot. And other times, like in this case, a suspect who probably could have been apprehended by more civil means and possibly rehabilitated, is left dead.
Although police suspected him of selling drugs, the transaction didn’t happen at his house.
Police could have arrested him when he committed the crime in the first place. Or police could have knocked on the door and arrested him, which is how many arrests are made. Police knew what he looked like and Bosket left his house regularly; police could have apprehended him in his front yard as he was leaving his house. Or stopped him while driving and taken him into custody. But raiding his house made the problem worse, left a cop injured, and a man dead. This scenario has repeated countless times before and will continue. We should stop armed raids on the homes of people suspected of nonviolent crimes, save for exceptional circumstances. It’s a matter of saving lives.










